In Ontario, a business is usually bought in one of two ways: by acquiring the shares of the corporation that owns it, or by acquiring the business’s assets directly. A share purchase transfers the whole company, history included. An asset purchase lets the buyer choose what it takes. The right structure depends on liability, tax, contracts, employees and the parties’ bargaining power.
Structure is one of the first points settled in a letter of intent, and it shapes everything that follows: the scope of due diligence, the purchase agreement, the tax bill and the closing mechanics. Buyers and sellers often want opposite answers. Toronto M&A lawyers spend a good part of early negotiations reconciling them.
Key Takeaways
- In a share purchase, the buyer acquires the corporation itself, including all of its liabilities, known and unknown.
- In an asset purchase, the buyer chooses which assets to acquire and which liabilities to assume. Some liabilities, such as employee service and certain environmental obligations, can still follow the business.
- Buyers generally prefer asset purchases for liability protection and tax depreciation. Sellers generally prefer share sales for a single level of tax and possible access to the lifetime capital gains exemption.
- Asset purchases usually require more third-party consents and conveyancing documents. Share purchases require broader due diligence.
- Only a corporation can be sold through a share sale. A sole proprietorship or partnership business must be sold as assets.
- The final structure is often a negotiated compromise, with price, indemnities or a pre-closing reorganization used to balance the tax and liability trade-offs.
What Is the Difference Between a Share Purchase and an Asset Purchase?
In a share purchase, the buyer acquires the shares of the corporation that carries on the business. The corporation stays the same legal entity. It continues to own its assets, remain party to its contracts, employ its staff and carry its liabilities. Only its owner changes.
In an asset purchase, the buyer, usually through a new corporation, acquires specific assets from the seller corporation. These can include equipment, inventory, real property, intellectual property, contracts and goodwill. The seller corporation remains in existence with whatever assets and liabilities the buyer did not take. It typically uses the sale proceeds to pay its debts before distributing the balance to its shareholders.
Share purchase
Asset purchase
What the buyer acquires
The corporation, with all its assets and liabilities
Selected assets and assumed liabilities only
Historic liabilities
Stay with the corporation, and so with the buyer
Generally stay with the seller, subject to exceptions
Contracts and permits
Remain in place, subject to change-of-control clauses
Must be assigned; consents often required
Employees
Employment continues unchanged
Buyer offers employment; service may still carry over
Tax preference
Usually favours the seller
Usually favours the buyer
Sales tax and land transfer tax
Share transfer generally exempt from HST; no land transfer tax on real property held by the corporation
HST may apply unless an election is made; land transfer tax on Ontario real property
Documentation
Simpler conveyance, broader due diligence
More conveyancing documents and consents
Liability: What the Buyer Inherits
Liability is the main reason buyers prefer asset purchases. When the buyer acquires shares, the corporation keeps its full legal history: unpaid taxes, past product claims, litigation, regulatory breaches and contractual disputes. A share purchase does not stop a customer from suing the corporation for a breach that occurred before closing. Once the deal closes, that claim is effectively the buyer’s problem.
An asset purchase lets the buyer leave unwanted liabilities with the seller, but the protection is not absolute:
- Security interests follow the assets. A lender’s security registered under Ontario’s Personal Property Security Act stays attached to the collateral unless it is discharged at closing. PPSA searches and payout letters are essential.
- Employees’ service can carry over. Under section 9 of the Employment Standards Act, 2000, an employee hired by the buyer of a business is generally treated as having continuous service. The buyer therefore inherits that service when calculating notice and severance.
- Union rights follow the business. In a unionized workplace, Ontario’s Labour Relations Act, 1995 generally binds the buyer of a business to the existing collective agreement as a successor employer.
- Environmental orders can reach new owners. Environmental regulators may issue orders to the current owner or the person in control of contaminated property, whoever caused the problem.
In a share purchase, the buyer’s protection comes from due diligence and from the seller’s representations, warranties and indemnities, often backed by a holdback or escrow.
Tax: Why Buyers and Sellers Usually Disagree
Tax is usually where the two sides’ interests diverge most, and it often drives the price.
Why sellers prefer selling shares. An individual who sells shares realizes a capital gain, of which only half is currently included in income. If the shares qualify as shares of a qualified small business corporation, the seller may be able to shelter a significant portion of the gain with the lifetime capital gains exemption. That exemption was raised to $1.25 million in 2024 and is indexed to inflation. Several family members may each be able to claim it if they hold shares. In an asset sale, by contrast, the seller corporation is taxed on the sale first, including any recapture of depreciation claimed in earlier years. The shareholders are then taxed again when they take the proceeds out of the corporation.
Why buyers prefer buying assets. In an asset purchase, the buyer’s tax cost of each asset generally equals the price allocated to it. That allows the buyer to claim capital cost allowance (tax depreciation) on equipment, buildings and goodwill based on what it actually paid. In a share purchase, the corporation keeps its existing, often lower, tax cost in its assets, and the buyer gets no immediate step-up.
Sales tax and land transfer tax. A sale of shares is generally exempt from HST. An asset sale is subject to HST unless the buyer and seller jointly elect under section 167 of the Excise Tax Act. That election is generally available when both are registrants and the buyer acquires all or substantially all of the property needed to carry on the business. An asset purchase that includes Ontario real property also triggers Ontario land transfer tax. A share purchase generally does not, because the corporation continues to own the property.
Non-resident sellers. When a non-resident sells “taxable Canadian property”, section 116 of the Income Tax Act requires a clearance certificate. Without one, the buyer may have to withhold and remit part of the price.
Because the tax consequences can be large, the parties often bridge the gap through the price. A seller that insists on a share sale may accept a lower price, and a buyer that insists on an asset purchase may pay more. The purchase price allocation in an asset deal should be negotiated with tax advisers involved from the start.
Contracts, Permits and Consents
In a share purchase, contracts, leases and permits generally remain with the corporation, which makes share deals attractive when the business depends on hard-to-transfer rights. Due diligence must still look for change-of-control clauses. A commercial lease, supply agreement or licence may let the other party terminate or require its consent if ownership changes. Shareholder agreements often contain transfer restrictions or rights of first refusal that must be waived as well.
In an asset purchase, each contract must be assigned to the buyer, and many contracts require the counterparty’s consent to an assignment. Some government licences and permits cannot be transferred at all and must be applied for again. If key customers, landlords or regulators are unlikely to cooperate, an asset purchase can become impractical.
Employees
In a share purchase, the employer does not change, so employment relationships carry on without interruption. The buyer inherits every existing employment contract, benefit plan and potential claim.
In an asset purchase, the seller’s employees do not automatically become the buyer’s employees. The buyer decides whom to offer employment to. As noted above, Ontario law generally gives continuity of service to employees the buyer does hire. The seller usually remains responsible for termination costs for those not offered employment. The purchase agreement should allocate those costs clearly.
Which Businesses Can Be Sold Through a Share Sale?
Only a corporation has shares. A business carried on by a sole proprietor or a partnership can be sold only as assets, unless it is first transferred into a corporation, which itself raises tax and timing questions.
Regulatory Approvals
The choice of structure rarely decides whether government approval is needed, but it can affect the analysis. Under the Competition Act, pre-merger notification is generally required when the parties’ combined Canadian assets or revenues exceed $400 million and the target’s Canadian assets or revenues exceed $93 million (2026). Share acquisitions are notifiable only if the buyer also crosses specified voting-interest thresholds. Under the Investment Canada Act, an acquisition of control of a Canadian business by a non-Canadian requires at least a notification, whether it is structured as a share or an asset deal.
Practical Considerations
A few practical points tend to decide the structure in practice:
- How clean is the corporation? A long operating history, past litigation or environmental exposure pushes buyers toward an asset purchase.
- How transferable are the key contracts and permits? If consents are hard to get, a share purchase may be the only realistic route.
- What is the seller’s tax position? If the seller’s shareholders can claim the lifetime capital gains exemption, they will resist an asset sale.
- Is there a middle ground? Pre-sale reorganizations, hybrid structures and price adjustments can sometimes give each side most of what it wants. These depend heavily on the facts and need coordinated legal and tax advice.
Example. A buyer wants to acquire a Toronto-area manufacturer. The manufacturer has valuable long-term supply contracts, but it also has an old environmental issue at a former site. A share purchase keeps the supply contracts in place but brings the environmental exposure with it. An asset purchase leaves that exposure behind, but it requires the customers’ consent to assign the contracts. The parties might agree on a share purchase backed by a specific environmental indemnity and an escrow. Alternatively, they might agree on an asset purchase conditional on obtaining the key customer consents before closing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a share purchase or an asset purchase better for the buyer?
Buyers generally prefer asset purchases. They can leave unwanted liabilities with the seller, and they get a higher tax cost in the assets for depreciation. A share purchase can still be the better choice when the business depends on contracts, leases or permits that are hard to transfer. Contractual protections, such as indemnities and holdbacks, can reduce the buyer’s risk in a share deal.
Why do sellers usually prefer to sell shares?
Selling shares usually means a single level of tax: individual shareholders realize a capital gain on the sale. If the shares are qualified small business corporation shares, part of the gain may be sheltered by the lifetime capital gains exemption. In an asset sale, the corporation is taxed on the sale first, and the shareholders are taxed again when they withdraw the proceeds.
Does a buyer in an asset purchase avoid all of the seller’s liabilities?
No. In Ontario, employees the buyer hires generally keep their prior service, and a unionized buyer may be bound by the existing collective agreement. Security interests stay attached to the assets unless they are discharged. Environmental orders may also be issued to the new owner of contaminated property. Due diligence and the purchase agreement should address each of these risks.
Do contracts need to be reassigned in a share purchase?
Generally not, because the corporation remains party to its contracts. Many commercial leases and supply or licence agreements, however, contain change-of-control clauses. These require the other party’s consent, or allow it to terminate, when ownership changes. Identifying those clauses is a key part of due diligence.
Is HST payable on the sale of a business in Ontario?
A sale of shares is generally exempt from HST. An asset sale is generally subject to HST unless the buyer and seller make a joint election under section 167 of the Excise Tax Act. The election is generally available when both are registrants and the buyer acquires all or substantially all of the property needed to carry on the business.
Can a sole proprietorship be sold as a share sale?
No. Only a corporation issues shares. A business carried on by an individual or a partnership is sold by transferring its assets. The owner can transfer the business into a corporation before the sale, but that step has its own tax and timing implications and should be planned with advisers.
Speak With Experienced Canadian Corporate Counsel
Choosing between a share purchase and an asset purchase is a legal, tax and commercial decision, and the right answer depends on the business and the people involved. Lazarus Legal advises buyers, sellers and investors on structuring and negotiating acquisitions in Ontario and across Canada. Our work covers letters of intent and due diligence through to purchase agreements and closing. If you are planning to buy or sell a business, our Toronto corporate lawyers can help you weigh the options before terms are fixed.
Visit lazaruslegal.com or contact us to arrange a consultation.
This article provides general information only and is not legal or tax advice. The right structure for any transaction depends on its specific facts.




